UPDATED: July 20, 2025
Welcome to the Healthy Living Is Good Medicine Newsletter, a totally free, health education publication covering a wide array of topics, with original articles presented as a public service to help people lead healthier lives.
Full disclosure of motivated reasoning: As an unrepentant lover of dark chocolate, I want to believe that plain dark chocolate, with at least 85% cocoa and minimal added sugar, is a health food that's good for the heart and brain. I eat some on an almost daily basis. It makes me happy, and contains some important phytonutrients. I hedge my bets by purchasing brands with lower levels of heavy metals, and keep the amount I eat to a minimum. Please engage your critical thinking skills as you read on.
A Brief History of Chocolate
Chocolate has made a fascinating journey from the ancient rainforests of South and Central America to the modern world, transforming from a sacred beverage used in religious ceremonies, to the sweet confections that we know and love today. Archaeological evidence suggests that cacao was first domesticated in equatorial South America 5,300 years ago.
The cacao tree, Theobroma cacao, whose Latin name translates to “Food of the Gods,” was cultivated by the Olmecs around 1500 BCE in what is now Mexico. The early Olmec, Maya, and Aztec civilizations knew that the cocoa beans from cacao pods could be processed into a bitter, frothy drink that had both medicinal and spiritual significance.
The Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire in 1519 brought chocolate to Spain, where it was jealously guarded as a state secret for nearly a century, after being adapted to European tastes by adding sugar and honey. By the 17th century, chocolate had become a luxury item in European courts. The Industrial Revolution transformed cocoa powder from its use in an elite beverage into a mass-produced commodity. The first solid chocolate bar was produced in 1847, and Swiss innovations created modern milk chocolate. West Africa currently produces more than 80 percent of the world's crop for an industry that's now worth over $130 billion annually.
Medicinal Applications
Cacao was valued for its perceived medicinal properties by the ancient Maya and Aztecs, who used it to treat a variety of ailments. During the 17th and 18th centuries, European physicians prescribed chocolate for digestive problems and as an energy tonic for the weak and elderly. Modern scientific research has validated the health benefits of dark chocolate with a high cacao content. Cacao beans are a rich source of dietary polyphenols, including flavonoids and particularly flavanols, which are powerful antioxidants and may reduce inflammation.
Studies have shown that moderate consumption of dark chocolate containing at least 70% cacao can have cardiovascular benefits. The flavanols in cacao could help improve blood flow, reduce blood pressure, and lower the risk of heart disease. Some research suggests that regular consumption of dark chocolate can improve the function of the vascular endothelium, which is crucial for healthy blood vessels. In contrast, milk chocolate and highly processed chocolate products contain much lower levels of beneficial compounds and higher amounts of sugar and fat, negating any potential health benefits.
A 2021 randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind, cross-over study found that cocoa-derived flavanols improved vascular responses to acute mental stress. The authors concluded that cocoa’s flavanols are effective in counteracting endothelial dysfunction due to psychological stressors, and can improve peripheral blood flow during periods of stress. These findings suggest that there may be some vascular health benefits from eating high-cocoa dark chocolate when we’re feeling stressed.
Because cocoa contains a variety of essential nutrients and bioactive compounds that could influence metabolic and vascular health, research is currently exploring chocolate's impact on cardiometabolic risk markers, endothelial function, and various cardiovascular outcomes. Results from a large randomized trial of a cocoa extract found that its consumption was associated with a 27 percent reduction in death from cardiovascular disease.
There is no convincing evidence that dark chocolate reduces arterial plaque formation or the risk of type 2 diabetes. Cocoa’s effects on lowering both heart rate and systolic blood pressure are mediated through the autonomic nervous system, rather than having any direct effects upon the heart.
While some studies found an association between cocoa consumption and increased parasympathetic nervous system activity, including increased heart rate variability (HRV), other studies found no significant correlation between the two. Low heart rate variability (HRV), an indicator of cardiac autonomic dysfunction, is a strong predictor of adverse cardiovascular events and mortality, and may also be associated with neurodegeneration and cognitive decline. Cocoa does not decrease HRV, nor does it conclusively increase it.
Even though some metabolic benefits do exist, the most immediate and well-supported vascular benefit of dark chocolate is its enhancement of nitric oxide production. According to a 2025 systematic review and meta‐analysis of randomized controlled trials, eating dark chocolate, when combined with physical activity, can benefit endothelial function by increasing nitric oxide, largely due to flavanoids that relax blood vessels and enhance vascular responsiveness, thereby improving oxygen delivery and reducing oxidative stress.
Regular cocoa consumption has been associated with modest reductions in total cholesterol, likely due to flavonoids. These compounds might reduce cholesterol absorption and LDL production. The effect appears more pronounced in individuals with existing health conditions. However, cocoa has not consistently found to lower triglycerides, because it lacks components that influence triglyceride levels. Although cocoa might modestly lower LDL, increases in HDL cholesterol have not been consistently reported, as it lacks the specific fats that typically raise HDL.
According to a 2023 systematic review and meta-analysis, cocoa consumption could conceivably be recommended as part of a healthy diet for people with both normal and elevated LDL cholesterol. A 2024 meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials suggests that cocoa has positive effects on major cardiometabolic risk markers, which may translate to cardiovascular risk reduction.
Oleic acid, a monounsaturated fat found in chocolate, has been linked to heart health benefits by supporting normal platelet function, according to a 2024 review. Saturated fats such as palmitic acid and stearic acid are also present in cocoa, but do not offer the same protection. Palmitic acid is associated with adverse effects on heart cell membranes, whereas stearic acid has a neutral impact on cholesterol and no clear cardiovascular benefit. Margaric acid, another saturated fat, is found in much smaller amounts.
Nutrition
Dark chocolate with a cocoa content greater than 70% could contain more antioxidants than green tea, blueberries, and acai, suggesting that chocolate might be considered a "health food" when consumed in moderation. It's flavanols (a phytochemical subclass of polyphenolic flavanoids) combat free radicals in the body, reducing oxidative stress and inflammation, which potentially lowers the risk of some diseases. They also act as prebiotics that encourage a diverse gut microbiome containing beneficial bacteria.
Cacao also contains several important minerals. Potassium, magnesium, phosphorus, and calcium are the most abundant minerals in cocoa beans, while sodium, copper, zinc, and iron are present only in small amounts. Magnesium and calcium are play a significant role in the regulation of blood pressure, muscle function, blood glucose control, and nerve conduction. Cocoa beans also contain significant levels of vitamins, particularly vitamins D, B1, B2, and E, according to 2025 review of cocoa's health impact.
The Darker Sides of Chocolate
The growing demand for chocolate has led to deforestation in many regions. Cocoa farming, especially when practiced as monoculture, can result in the clear-cutting and burning of rainforests to make way for new plantations. There are, however, some initiatives that promote and support sustainable cocoa farming practices that can minimize deforestation and protect the impacted ecosystems.
Cocoa contains caffeine and theobromine, both of which are stimulants. If you're sensitive to caffeine, especially when its consumed later in the day, because it results in difficulties in falling asleep, this could be a factor in choosing to avoid chocolate. You have my deepest sympathies.
Interestingly, those two substances are toxic for many other animals that lack the human enzymes that metabolize them. Chocolate poisoning occurs most commonly in dogs, potentially causing life-threatening cardiac arrhythmias and central nervous system dysfunction.
The suggestion that chocolate can trigger migraine headaches is debatable. A 2020 review of the literature concluded that provocative studies have failed to elicit significant differences between migraine attacks induced by eating chocolate and a placebo. The evidence that chocolate is a migraine trigger is thus far insufficient. However, migraine triggers can vary significantly from person to person, and your mileage may vary.
Cocoa contains oxalates, and dark chocolate is considered a high-oxalate food that people prone to calcium oxalate kidney stones should consume cautiously. Studies show a total oxalate content ranging from 155 to 485 mg per 100 grams dry weight. The consumption of less than 80 mg of oxalate per day is considered a low-oxalate diet. That's equivalent to eating no more than 30 grams (about 1 ounce) of 70% dark chocolate per day. The same amount of 90% dark chocolate can contain over 120 mg of oxalate.
Oxalate absorption appears to occur throughout the entire gastrointestinal tract, and dietary oxalate can make a considerable contribution to urinary oxalate output. Calcium-rich dairy products and probiotics that contain oxalate-degrading bacteria have the potential to reduce oxaluria and the risk of nephrolithiasis. Milk chocolate contains less oxalate, but more sugar and fat, and that creates a whole other set of health risks.
Of more general concern is the lead and cadmium content of some chocolate formulations. Consumer Reports testing found that a third of chocolate products are high in these very toxic heavy metals, and every product tested had detectable amounts of lead and cadmium, which poses the question, “How concerned should we be?”
Cocoa plants appear to take up cadmium from the soil, while lead can be deposited on the cocoa beans by soil dust while the beans are drying outdoors. Dark chocolate and cocoa powder tend to have the highest amounts of heavy metals. While “the dose makes the poison,” lead is a cumulative toxin that’s slow to be eliminated. It remains in bones and teeth indefinitely. It’s a matter of both the dose, and how often it is repeated.
Of note was that “organic” chocolate products were significantly more likely to demonstrate higher levels of both metals. Exposure to heavy metals is of particular concern for children and fetuses, and pregnant women should be made aware of the risks. Damage to growing brains can cause developmental delays, learning difficulties, and behavior problems.
Adults could certainly experience negative metabolic effects from over-consumption, and as always, moderation is key. It recently came to my attention that a German-style chocolate cake recipe, secretly titled “Death By Chocolate,” won first prize out of 150 or so entries at a state fair... and I can't wait to try it.
The good news is that a multi-year analysis concluded that a single daily serving of chocolate may not pose any appreciable risk for the average person, but who among us has the willpower to stick to to just one serving when it’s love at first bite, followed by extraordinary feelings of ecstasy? Presented with the cake above, it would be hard not to eat the whole thing in one sitting. Hence, its name.
For an in-depth look at this study, see:
Chocolate on My Mind
There are a number of psychoactive compounds in chocolate. Caffeine and theobromine have mild stimulant effects that can enhance mood and improve cognitive functions such as memory and focus. Chocolate also stimulates the production of endorphins (endogenous opioids), hormones such as oxytocin, and neurotransmitters, including dopamine, phenylethylamine, serotonin, and anandamide (an endocannabinoid associated with feelings of bliss), all of which contribute to experiencing pleasure and an enhanced sense of well-being.
The ancient civilizations of Meso-America considered cacao to be an aphrodisiac. The impact of chocolate on brain chemistry and romantic love show surprising similarities. Both activate brain pathways associated with pleasure, reward, and emotional bonding, and produce feelings of excitement, euphoria, and even obsession. In a sense, both chocolate and romantic love can become mildly addictive. However, if you're hooked on that feeling, chocolate is much less likely to lead you astray than does falling head over heels in love.
A 2022 randomized controlled trial involving 48 healthy young adults showed that chocolate containing 85% cocoa had prebiotic effects, resulting in a restructuring of the diversity and abundance of intestinal bacteria. There was a statistically significant improvement in mood among those who ate 10 grams, three times a day for three weeks, but not in the control group or those who ate 70% cocoa chocolate. The authors suggest that cocoa may act as a mood elevator via the gut-brain axis.
A 2022 systematic review of experimental evidence suggests that chocolate contains biologically active molecules that may help with cognition as people age. Some research has even suggested that it might reduce the risk of depression and stimulate neuroplasticity that could slow the progression of neurodegenerative conditions such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease.
If you're as much of a chocolate lover as I am, you will surely appreciate Dr. Tamy Faierman's ode to this “Food of the Gods.”
While chocolate doesn't cause true addiction in the clinical sense, it can trigger psychological dependence and intense cravings. Ultra-processed chocolate products may be particularly prone to triggering addictive-like behaviors due to their combination of sugar, fat, and artificial additives used to enhance palatability. The combination of chocolate's neurochemical effects, along with its taste, texture, and cultural associations with comfort and love, can create psychologically powerful attachments. If you want to get over your chocolate cravings, it will require a couple of weeks of relatively painless total abstinence.
If you are actually able to enjoy eating the much healthier, unsweetened, 100% cocoa known as “baking chocolate,” you may be a true “chocoholic,” ie. a person with strong psychophysiological attachments to the effects of chocolate on their brain. If that's you, welcome to our group: “Hi, I'm Dr. Mick. I'm a chocoholic, and that makes me happy.” No efforts toward recovery are expected here.
Chocolate Equals Love
In addition to the impact of chocolate upon the brain’s biochemistry, there are cultural influences at play. In America, Valentine's Day is consistently one of the biggest chocolate consumption days of the year. It ranks third, behind Halloween and Easter, in terms of the sheer volume of chocolate sales.
Surveys indicate that about two-thirds of Americans typically eat chocolate on Valentine's Day. While a box of assorted chocolates remains an iconic Valentine's Day gift, if you want to show that you also care about the health of your loved one, give them dark chocolate with at least 85% cocoa instead. Or, do what I do, and give the gift of chocolate to yourself. Any time of the year is fine, and you don’t need a Hallmark Holiday as an excuse.
― ― ―
This Post can be updated at any time. Please check back here again to find the most recent version.
You can find many more articles about Healthy Living in my Post Archive.
Please share my Website Link with others via your social media accounts. You can help your friends and followers become healthier by suggesting that they subscribe to my totally free Newsletter.